Home Insurance, CA Fair Plan, and Escrow Confusion…Need Advice

Trying to get a handle on this complex insurance setup and how it works with Escrow. Here’s the background:

  • Bought a 4-acre property in 2020 (El Dorado County, CA)
  • Property has 1 loan with 1 loan number, but includes 2 houses on 1 parcel (main house and granny flat)
  • We live in the main house (#102) and rent out the granny flat (#100) as an Airbnb

Current policies:

  • Main house (#102) has CA Fair Plan for fire and Bamboo for general home insurance
  • Granny flat (#100) has CA Fair Plan for fire and Aegis business insurance for home coverage

Problem:

My mortgage company only acknowledges the two policies for the granny flat (#100), which matches the loan’s address. Every time I mention the main house (#102) and its policies, they get confused and request either a change of address on the policy or another loan number, which we don’t have. As a result, only 2 out of the 4 policies are covered in Escrow.

I’ve heard of other properties that managed similar setups with both homes’ policies covered in Escrow. Is it possible to get all 4 policies included in Escrow for both houses? My broker suggested there might be a way if there’s something in the closing documents that clarifies the property’s setup. Any advice?

This seems more like a loan servicing question than an insurance issue. You might have better luck asking on a home loan forum.

Briar said:
This seems more like a loan servicing question than an insurance issue. You might have better luck asking on a home loan forum.

Thanks, I’ll give r/homeloans a try for more guidance.

@Oaklan
Here’s a preview of /r/HomeLoans with top posts from the past year! Check them out here.