How would you respond to this?
The roof is good, the inspector remarked, no leaks, no missing shingles, just ancient.
I fear that homeowners insurance will want it replaced before to issuing us a coverage, or even worse, that they will provide us a policy only to later claim that the item needs to be replaced following the closing.
Is it worthwhile to haggle over this with the sellers? They may just as easily assume that the roof is good as it is right now.
Worth requesting half the price?